With the bevy of “best of” year-end book lists appearing, I thought it time to re-visit Jonathan Franzen’s Freedom which seems to be the 800 pound gorilla in the collective room, either appearing on the list (see Salon’s editors’ picks, The New York Times ten best books) or being trumpeted as absent from the list (Slate’s books, Salon’s authors’ lists). Already seemingly forgotten is the controversy that the Tanenhaus review in The New York Times Book Review engendered, a not wholly off-base gnashing of teeth over the critical circle jerk that greeted Franzen’s book, with complaints about why such a middling book is getting the full masterpiece treatment and pointing out that in our literary culture, male writers get an inordinate amount of this kind of “capturing the zeitgeist” adulation. I have to admit to some surprise that Freedom commands such year-end attention. Collective critical opinion tends to settle over time and I thought given the basic mediocrity of the book that a lot of critics, now freed up from that initial critical lockstep, would simply allow it to drift away unremarked upon (and to be fair, after sampling a number of such lists, Freedom is hardly a ubiquitous presence). Continue reading
Twitter Updates
- @TheyMightBeJeff @RoverGrover @RonFilipkowski This is utter bullshit and you have to know it. Hillary did better in… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 1 day ago
- @realStanVG Yes, I was trying to find a way to say "right of Scalia, can you believe it!!" but didn't have the room. 2 days ago
- @realStanVG @RexChapman That's one of the central ironies of the MAGA concept; it's so reduced this country in the… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 2 days ago
- @realStanVG Before Heller 2008, no court had ever defined the 2nd amendment as containing an individual right to be… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 2 days ago
- This is how a minority stays in power. And Thomas is clearly a nightmare who needs to be removed but probably cann… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 2 days ago